A co-founder wants out: what the documents, the law and the next buyer decide
A co-founder departure is settled less at the table than in documents signed years earlier. Vesting and acceleration, transfer limits and investor consents, whether the company may legally pay, the tax result on each side, and what leaves with a technical founder, read the way a buyer’s counsel will read it later.
The short answer. A co-founder departure is decided less at the negotiating table than in documents signed years earlier: the restricted stock agreement, the 83(b) election or its absence, the acceleration definitions, the transfer restrictions, the investor documents and the invention assignment. Those documents set how many shares are still at risk, who may buy them, at what price, with whose consent and with what tax result for each side. The economics then depend on things founders rarely model: that common stock is not a pro rata slice of the last round, that a company may not legally be able to pay, that a redemption can cost other shareholders a tax exclusion, and that a buyer will later ask for proof of every step. Handled well, a departure is a closed file in a data room. Handled loosely, it becomes a capitalization question, an indemnity and an escrow in the next deal.
1. The documents decide more than the negotiation
Vesting and the repurchase right
Founder stock is usually issued up front as restricted stock, with the company holding a right to repurchase the unvested part when the founder stops providing services. A common schedule is four years with a one-year cliff, and the repurchase price for unvested shares is typically the price the founder paid, often nominal, as Mintz describes. Some agreements go further and let the company repurchase vested shares too, for example after a termination for cause or a breach of a restrictive covenant. Read which version you signed before anyone speaks about price: it decides whether the conversation is about a buyback at cost or a purchase at value.
How the departure is labelled changes the share count
Acceleration provisions turn on definitions. A founder who resigns, a founder terminated without cause and a founder who resigns for "good reason" can end up with different numbers of vested shares under the same agreement, especially where double-trigger acceleration covers a termination after a change of control. The label is therefore not a courtesy. It is an economic term, and each side's counsel will treat it that way.
The 83(b) question
An election under section 83(b) must be filed within 30 days of the transfer of restricted stock. With a timely election, the founder was taxed at grant on the difference between the value of the stock and the price paid, usually close to nothing, and later vesting is not a tax event. Without one, each tranche that vested was compensation income at its value on vesting, less what was paid for it. A missing election is often discovered for the first time at departure or when a buyer's counsel asks for copies of every founder's filing, which is a standard request.
Transfer restrictions and price mechanisms
A buy-sell agreement or transfer restrictions in the bylaws decide who may buy and how the price is set. The three usual mechanisms each fail in a known way. A fixed price goes stale within a year. A formula, such as a multiple of revenue or earnings, freezes one moment of the market into the contract. An appraisal clause is only as good as its definitions: one appraiser or three, who pays, how fast, and above all the standard of value. Whether the price is fair market value of the stake itself, with discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability, or a pro rata share of the whole company without discounts, often moves the result as much as the argument about the multiple.
Investor documents
In a venture-backed company, the standard documents usually include a right of first refusal and co-sale agreement (the company first, then major investors, may buy shares a founder proposes to sell; investors may sell alongside) and a voting agreement with board designation rights and often a drag-along. Two details matter at departure. A board seat designated by the holders of common, or reserved for a founder while employed, may change hands. And the charter's protective provisions typically require the preferred holders' consent for the company to repurchase stock, with an exception for buying back shares from departing service providers at no more than their original price. A repurchase of vested shares at value therefore usually needs investor approval, not only a board vote.
2. A stake is not a slice of the headline valuation
A founder holding 20 percent of the common stock of a company whose last round was priced at a given post-money valuation does not hold 20 percent of that number. The round priced preferred stock, with a liquidation preference and other rights that common does not have. In a sale, the preferences are paid first; what reaches common depends on the price and the stack above it. Valuing the departing founder's stake means running the waterfall at realistic exit values, not multiplying a percentage by the last round.
Three further points shape the price.
- Minority and marketability. A non-controlling stake in a private company is worth less per share than control of the whole, and professional appraisals reflect both discounts unless the agreement excludes them.
- The 409A value. Valuation firms consider recent transactions in common stock when they set its fair market value for option pricing. A buyback or secondary at a price well above the current 409A value can raise the strike price of the next employee grants. A price well below it can raise the opposite question.
- Insurance-funded agreements. Many buy-sell agreements were written for death, funded by company-owned life insurance. In Connelly v. United States (2024) the Supreme Court held that the company's obligation to redeem shares at fair market value does not offset the insurance proceeds when the company is valued for estate tax. Agreements of that design deserve a review with tax counsel, and the review is a good moment to fix the departure terms in the same document.
3. Can the company legally pay, and on what terms
A redemption is a distribution to a shareholder, and corporate law limits it. Under section 160 of the Delaware General Corporation Law, a corporation may not purchase or redeem its own shares when its capital is impaired or when the purchase would impair it, and section 174 makes directors who approve an unlawful redemption jointly and severally liable for up to six years. Other states apply their own solvency tests. Before the board approves a buyback, it should see the balance sheet test done properly, not assumed.
Lenders limit it too. Credit agreements commonly restrict payments to shareholders, including redemptions, without the lender's consent. Venture debt is no exception.
Young companies rarely pay in cash at once, so the usual instrument is a promissory note to the departing founder. The note's terms carry most of the later risk: whether it is subordinated to bank debt, whether it is secured, what happens on default, and whether it accelerates on a change of control, in which case a future buyer pays it off at closing and will want to know the amount. A price that depends on the company's later results keeps the former founder economically tied to decisions they no longer influence, which is a known source of disputes.
4. Tax: the same buyback can be a sale for one side and a problem for another
For the departing founder, a redemption is treated as a sale or exchange, rather than as a distribution taxed like a dividend, when it qualifies under section 302, most cleanly as a complete termination of interest. Family attribution can defeat that: shares held by a spouse, a parent or a child count as the founder's own. The rules allow those attribution rules to be waived, but only if, immediately after the redemption, the founder keeps no interest in the corporation, including as an officer, director or employee, other than as a creditor, acquires none for ten years, and files the required agreement. A founder who wants to stay on the board, or to be paid as an employee for a transition period, needs that conflict resolved by a tax adviser before the documents are signed, not after.
For the other shareholders, the risk sits in section 1202, the qualified small business stock exclusion. Stock does not qualify if the corporation bought its own stock from the holder or a related person in the four years beginning two years before the stock was issued. Separately, stock issued in a two-year window beginning one year before the issuance loses qualification if, during that window, the company made purchases of its own stock worth more than 5 percent of the value of all its stock. A large co-founder redemption can therefore cost investors and employees who receive stock around the same time an exclusion they were counting on. Regulations provide limited exceptions, including for certain repurchases connected with the end of a person's services, and their conditions need to be checked case by case. For stock acquired after July 4, 2025, the exclusion now starts at 50 percent after three years, rises to 75 percent after four and reaches 100 percent after five, with a per-issuer cap of $15 million and a gross assets limit of $75 million.
This is one of the reasons a secondary sale is sometimes preferred to a redemption. When another investor buys the shares, the company makes no purchase of its own stock. The buyer of the secondary shares, however, does not get the exclusion, because it applies only to stock acquired at original issue, and the departing founder's own holding period decides what they can exclude on the sale.
5. Roles, votes and the hold-up problem
The separation itself should be documented as carefully as the share transfer: written resignations from the board and from every officer position, return of property and credentials, a mutual release of claims, confidentiality, non-solicitation and a cooperation clause that obliges the former founder to sign documents and answer questions in a future financing or sale. Non-competes are a matter of state law; several states restrict them for employees but allow them in connection with the sale of a business interest, and the federal ban adopted by the FTC in 2024 was set aside by a court before it took effect.
The release and the cooperation clause matter more than founders expect. In a sale, a buyer usually wants every significant holder to sign support documents and a release, whatever the vote required by law. A former founder with a meaningful stake and no obligation to cooperate has leverage at exactly the moment the remaining founders have the least time. A drag-along signed years ago reduces that leverage. Its absence increases it.
Undocumented promises are the last item. Equity promised by e-mail or in conversation and never issued, or a percentage someone believes they were offered, becomes a claim when the company is worth more. A departure is the right moment to list every such promise and close it in writing.
6. What leaves with a technical co-founder
This is the part of a departure our technical reviews see most often, and it is where documents alone do not help.
- Invention assignment. A proprietary information and inventions assignment agreement covers work after it is signed. Code written before incorporation, or before the agreement, needs a separate technology assignment. Check the prior inventions schedule too: a founder who listed the core idea there may have excluded it from the assignment.
- Where the code lives. Repositories under a personal account, company code in personal forks, commits signed with a personal e-mail, and open source packages the product depends on but the founder published personally.
- Accounts tied to one person. Domain registrant of record, DNS, the cloud provider's root or management account and its billing, the identity provider's super admin, the code host's organization owner, the payment processor account opened on the founder's identity, code signing certificates, and the app store developer accounts, where the platform's own transfer process can take time. Second factors on a personal phone and secrets in a personal password manager belong on the same list. Moving all of it before the departure is announced is routine. After it, it depends on goodwill.
- Knowledge. Version control history shows which parts of the system only one person has changed in the last two years. Those parts need written architecture decisions, runbooks and a handover with someone who will own them. A paid transition period helps, and its form, employment or consulting, interacts with the tax point in section 4.
Our notes on ownership gaps in a software acquisition and key person risk in technical due diligence describe how buyers test each of these.
7. How a buyer will read the departure
A buyer's counsel will ask for the stock ledger, the repurchase or transfer documents, the board and stockholder consents, the investor consents where required, the 83(b) filings, the separation agreement and the release. Gaps turn into a capitalization representation the sellers cannot give cleanly, a specific indemnity, a larger escrow or holdback, or a closing condition that the former founder signs a release. Each of these has a price, and the price is paid by the people who stayed. A departure in the year before a process will also be asked about on the first management call. A short, true, documented account answers it. An improvised one starts a longer diligence.
Our note on why good businesses sell for less shows how such findings become price.
8. Who advises whom, and how they are paid
The company's counsel represents the company, not either founder, and the departing founder needs their own. Investors protect their position: they want the unvested shares back in the pool, no large passive holder, and sometimes the chance to buy a secondary at a discount. A sell-side adviser paid mostly when a sale closes has a reason to see a founder departure as the moment to sell the whole company. None of this is bad faith; it is how each role is paid, and a founder should know whose interest each piece of advice carries before weighing it.
Questions to answer before you talk numbers
- How many shares are vested on each possible label of the departure, and which label applies?
- Were 83(b) elections filed, and can you produce the copies?
- Which consents does the repurchase or transfer need: board, preferred holders, lenders?
- Does the company pass the legal test for a redemption today, and after the payments under a note?
- What does the waterfall give the common stake at realistic exit values?
- Does a redemption affect anyone's qualified small business stock, and would a secondary avoid it?
- Will the departing founder keep any role, and does that conflict with the tax treatment they expect?
- What still sits in the founder's name: code, accounts, domains, certificates, knowledge?
- What will a buyer's counsel ask for about this departure, and is every answer already on paper?
Where we fit
A co-founder departure is a decision about the company's future as much as about one person's shares. Our Second Opinion looks at it from outside: two private calls and a written report on how buyers and investors would see the company after the departure, the options side by side, including a sale, a secondary, a new round and "not yet", and what to do first. It takes neither founder's side, and its fee does not depend on what you choose. You can download a sample report to see the form. When the founder who leaves is the technical one, a technical review of the product, the code and the accounts shows what the company owns and what might leave with that person.
We do not broker sales, value shares, act for one founder against another, or take referral or success fees, and nothing here is legal, tax, accounting or investment advice. The repurchase, the transfer, the note, the separation agreement and the tax treatment on each side belong with qualified counsel and tax advisers, a separate set for each side.
Sources
- 26 U.S. Code § 1202, Cornell Law School LII: qualified small business stock, purchases by the corporation of its own stock, the 2025 holding periods and limits.
- 26 U.S. Code § 302, Cornell Law School LII: redemptions as sales, complete termination and the waiver of family attribution.
- Delaware General Corporation Law, §§ 160 and 174: limits on redemptions and directors' liability.
- Connelly v. United States, 602 U.S. (2024): redemption obligations and life insurance proceeds in valuing a company.
- National Venture Capital Association, model legal documents: right of first refusal and co-sale agreement, voting agreement, charter.
Questions
What happens to a departing co-founder's unvested shares?
Founder stock is usually restricted stock, and the company holds a right to repurchase the unvested part, typically at the price the founder paid. How the departure is labelled, a resignation, a termination without cause or a resignation for good reason, can change how many shares are vested under acceleration provisions. Some agreements also allow a repurchase of vested shares, for example after a termination for cause.
Can a company always buy back a co-founder's vested shares?
No. Corporate law limits redemptions: in Delaware a corporation may not redeem shares when its capital is impaired or would be, and directors who approve an unlawful redemption can be personally liable. In venture-backed companies the preferred holders' consent is usually required for a repurchase at value, and credit agreements often restrict payments to shareholders without the lender's consent.
How is a co-founder's stake valued?
Not as a percentage of the last round. Common stock sits below the preferred stock's liquidation preferences, so the stake is valued by running the waterfall at realistic exit values, and a non-controlling private stake usually carries discounts for lack of control and marketability unless the agreement excludes them. The price can also affect the 409A value of common stock and the strike price of future employee options.
Is a co-founder buyback taxed as a sale or as a dividend?
It is treated as a sale or exchange when it qualifies under section 302 of the Internal Revenue Code, most cleanly as a complete termination of the founder's interest. Shares held by close family count as the founder's own unless family attribution is waived, and the waiver requires that the founder keep no role as officer, director or employee for ten years. A founder who wants to stay on the board needs that resolved by a tax adviser before signing.
Can buying out a co-founder affect other shareholders' QSBS exclusion?
It can. Under section 1202, stock issued within a two-year window loses qualified small business stock status if the company bought back more than 5 percent of the value of its stock during that window, and a redemption from a holder can disqualify that holder's own stock issued nearby. Regulations provide limited exceptions, including some repurchases connected with the end of a person's services. A secondary sale to another investor is not a purchase by the company, which is one reason it is sometimes preferred.
What should a technical co-founder hand over before leaving?
The company should own the code through signed invention and technology assignments that also cover work done before incorporation, and hold every account in its own name: domain registrant, DNS, cloud root and billing, identity provider admin, code host organization, payment processor, code signing certificates and app store developer accounts. Parts of the system only that person has changed should get written architecture decisions, runbooks and a named new owner.
