For founders10 min read

An offer you did not ask for: what to do before you reply

An approach you did not invite starts someone else’s process. Who is really writing and with whose money, what the NDA must say, what to disclose and when, why a $12 million offer can mean $4.8 million at closing, the tax structure, and how to shape exclusivity before you sign it.

The short answer. An unsolicited approach is the start of someone else's process, run on their timetable and with their information advantage. Answering it well is not about the first reply, which can be three polite sentences. It is about what you decide before the second message: who is really writing and with whose money, what the confidentiality agreement must say, what you disclose at each stage, how you will compare a headline number with the cash you would actually receive, which tax structure you need, and what you will refuse to sign into exclusivity. Most of the value a seller loses in an inbound deal is lost in those decisions, usually long before anyone negotiates a purchase agreement.

1. Read the sender before the letter

The same friendly paragraph can come from buyers with very different needs, money and certainty of closing.

  • Strategic buyers. A competitor or a company in an adjacent line of business. They can often pay the most, because they can count synergies, and they learn the most from the conversation, because they understand your market. With a competitor, the conversation also carries antitrust limits on what may be exchanged before closing.
  • Private equity platforms. A fund-owned company adding businesses to itself. In 2025, add-on deals made up about 73 percent of US private equity buyouts by count. The letter may be signed by the platform's founder, but the decision, the model and the purchase agreement come from the fund's deal team, with institutional terms.
  • Search funds and independent sponsors. Individuals looking for one company to buy and run. A search fund usually has investors behind the search itself; an independent sponsor typically raises equity for each deal after agreeing terms with the seller. Both can be serious buyers; the certainty of their financing is the question to ask early.
  • Intermediaries. Brokers and advisers who write as if they were buyers, to win a listing or to bring you to a client for a fee.
  • Corporate development outreach. Larger companies keep in touch with many smaller ones to build a pipeline. Such a letter signals interest in your space, not an intention to buy now.

Before you answer anything of substance, you want five facts: who will own the company, where the money comes from and whether it is committed, which deals of your size they have closed, what happened to the founders and teams of those companies, and who approves a deal on their side. A serious buyer answers these quickly. Our note on who buys small businesses in 2026 covers each type in more detail.

2. The confidentiality agreement is a negotiated document

Buyers send their own form, and their form protects the reader of information more than the owner of it. The points worth negotiating:

  • Scope. Confidential information should include the fact of the discussions and their terms, information given orally, and everything derived from what you provide.
  • Residuals. A residuals clause lets the recipient use what its people retain in unaided memory. In a conversation with a competitor, that clause can make the rest of the agreement close to meaningless. Strike it.
  • Non-solicitation and no-contact. The buyer should not hire your employees or approach your customers, suppliers or staff about the deal without your consent, for a period that outlasts the talks.
  • Term, return and destruction. A term that survives a failed deal, and an obligation to return or destroy material, with realistic exceptions for automatic backups that remain under the same confidentiality.
  • Who is bound. Advisers, financing sources and, for a platform, the fund behind it.

With a competitor, there is a second layer. The Federal Trade Commission has warned that sharing competitively sensitive information before closing, such as current and future prices, strategic plans and costs, can itself violate antitrust law, and that parties who need such information for diligence should use clean teams and third-party consultants, with clean teams that exclude anyone responsible for pricing, planning or strategy. That is a matter for antitrust counsel, and it is also a practical protection: the deal may not close, and the competitor will still be a competitor.

3. Disclose in stages, and decide the stages in advance

A workable sequence for an inbound approach:

  1. Before any agreement: only what is public.
  2. After the confidentiality agreement: an overview of the business, summary financials for recent years, revenue mix and the shape of the customer base without names, and the team structure without individuals.
  3. After a written indication of interest with a range: more detailed financials, cohort and retention figures, the product and technology at the level of architecture.
  4. After a letter of intent you are willing to sign: the data room, customer contracts, pricing, employee details, and technical access in a controlled form.

Source code is rarely needed before a letter of intent and should not leave your control before one. When a buyer needs a technical view early, a session with your engineers or a seller-side technical report answers the question without handing over the asset. Our vendor due diligence exists for that moment.

4. The headline number is not what you receive

Buyers usually speak in enterprise value on a cash-free, debt-free basis with a normal level of working capital. What reaches the seller is that number after a series of adjustments and after a structure that defers or puts part of it at risk. A hypothetical example shows how far apart the two can be.

Hypothetical offerAmount
Headline price, of which $2.0M is an earnout$12.0M
Less the earnout, paid later only if targets are met−$2.0M
Less debt repaid at closing−$0.8M
Less deferred revenue the buyer treats as debt-like−$0.6M
Less the shortfall of working capital against the agreed target−$0.3M
Less equity rolled into the buyer's company−$2.0M
Less the escrow held for claims−$1.0M
Less the seller's transaction costs−$0.5M
Cash at closing, before tax$4.8M

None of these items is unusual, and each is negotiable. Whether deferred revenue is debt-like, how the working capital target is set, how long the escrow lasts and against which claims, who controls the business during an earnout and how its metric is defined, and what the rolled equity is worth and when it can be sold: these are where an offer's real value is decided. Comparing two offers means comparing cash at closing, the probability-weighted value of what is deferred, and the result after tax, not two headline numbers.

The first number spoken also matters. A figure a founder names on an early call becomes a ceiling. It is reasonable to say that you have not set a price, and to ask for a range in writing once the buyer has seen enough. A written range from a buyer tells you how it sees you; a number from you, given too early, only tells the buyer how you see yourself.

5. The tax structure is decided in the letter of intent

Buyers generally prefer to buy assets, or to buy stock in a way treated as an asset purchase for tax, because it gives them a stepped-up tax basis to depreciate and amortize. For a C corporation, a sale of assets can mean tax at the company level and again when proceeds are distributed. For an S corporation or a limited liability company, buyers often use structures that give them the step-up while the seller sells equity, such as a pre-closing reorganization or an election that treats a stock purchase as an asset purchase. A seller holding qualifying C corporation stock may be able to exclude part or all of the gain under the qualified small business stock rules, which our note on a co-founder who wants out describes in detail.

The point for an inbound approach is timing. The structure is usually written into the letter of intent, and after exclusivity it is hard to change. The difference between structures can be larger than the difference between two buyers' prices. A tax adviser should see the structure before you sign, not after.

6. The letter of intent and exclusivity

In the United States, a letter of intent is usually not binding, except for provisions such as confidentiality and exclusivity. Exclusivity is very common, stops you from talking to other buyers and from sharing information with them, and commonly runs for 30 to 60 days, sometimes longer. From that moment, the buyer is alone at the table and its diligence team starts asking for everything. What it finds tends to come back as price changes and new conditions; our notes on what a buyer's analysts ask for and why good businesses sell for less describe how.

A seller cannot avoid exclusivity, but can shape it:

  • the shortest period that is realistic for the buyer's diligence, with no automatic extension;
  • a fall-away if the buyer proposes a lower price or materially different terms, so a re-trade releases you;
  • milestones inside the period, such as evidence of financing and a first draft of the purchase agreement by a set date;
  • before signing, agreement on the terms that decide the real price: the working capital method and target, escrow size and duration, the indemnity cap and survival, whether representations and warranties insurance will be used, earnout metrics and operating control, and the founders' roles and restrictive covenants after closing.

Every term left for "the definitive agreement" will be negotiated when you have the least leverage. Any letter of intent should be read by your attorney before you sign it.

7. Whether one buyer is the market

A single interested buyer has more leverage than several. In the latest survey of business brokers and M&A advisers, the chairman of the brokers' association put it plainly: above about two million dollars, strong businesses still draw real competition, while at the smallest end buyers have more leverage. An unsolicited approach is often a reason to find out what others would pay. That does not have to mean a public auction. A quiet approach to a handful of logical buyers, made before exclusivity, can tell you whether the first offer is the market or a discount to it.

If the approach leads you to hire an adviser, read the engagement letter as carefully as the letter of intent. The points that matter most here are the fee on a buyer who approached you before the engagement, the tail period during which a fee is still due after the engagement ends, and any minimum fee. Agree how the buyer already at the table is treated before you sign.

8. What the buyer's technical review will find

For a software or technology-enabled business, the technical review after the letter of intent is where many price changes start. The findings that most often become price or conditions are predictable: code and designs the company does not clearly own because assignments are missing, open source components whose license obligations the product does not meet, frameworks and platforms past their support dates, security incidents that were never documented, and parts of the system only one person understands. Our notes on ownership gaps and support deadlines in a deal show how buyers read them.

Each of these is cheaper to find yourself, before exclusivity, when the finding is yours to explain and to fix. Our note on a technical baseline before selling describes what that looks like.

What a first reply can look like

A short, polite reply keeps the door open without giving anything away. For example:

Thank you for reaching out. We are not running a sale process, but I am always glad to understand how others see our market. Could you tell me a little more about your company, the deals you have done, and what you have in mind? If it makes sense to talk further, we would ask for a mutual NDA before sharing anything beyond what is public.

It does not say yes, it does not say no, and it asks the questions you need answered. Then take your time. A buyer who is serious will wait a week.

When the letter is a signal, not an offer

Even if you never answer, an approach tells you something: someone looked at your company and saw value worth a letter. It is a good moment to ask the questions you may have postponed. How would a buyer or an investor see the company today, what raises its value and what lowers it, what your options are, including staying independent, and what you would want to change before any of them.

That is the question our Second Opinion is built for: two private calls and a written report on how buyers and investors would see your company, your options side by side, including "not yet", and what to do first. Its fee is the same whatever you decide. You can download a sample report to see what it looks like. We compare options; the decision stays yours.

We do not broker sales, introduce buyers, negotiate deals or take referral or success fees, and nothing here is legal, tax, accounting or investment advice. Confidentiality agreements, letters of intent, antitrust questions and the purchase agreement belong with your attorney; the tax structure of any deal with your tax adviser.

Sources

Questions

Should I reply to an unsolicited offer to buy my company?

Usually yes, briefly and politely, after you have decided what you want. Before answering anything of substance, learn who will own the company, whether the money is committed, which deals of your size the buyer has closed, what happened to those founders, and who approves the deal. Share nothing beyond what is public before a confidentiality agreement.

What should a confidentiality agreement with a potential buyer include?

Confidential information should cover the fact of the talks and everything derived from what you share. Strike any residuals clause, which lets the recipient use what its people remember. Add non-solicitation of your employees and a ban on contacting your customers, suppliers or staff without consent, a term that survives a failed deal, return or destruction of material, and make sure advisers, financing sources and any fund behind a platform are bound.

Why is the cash I receive lower than the offer price?

Offers are usually stated as enterprise value on a cash-free, debt-free basis with a normal level of working capital. Debt, debt-like items such as deferred revenue in some deals, a working capital shortfall, the escrow, an earnout, rolled equity and transaction costs all come off before cash at closing. Compare offers on cash at closing, the probability-weighted value of what is deferred, and the result after tax.

How long does exclusivity in a letter of intent last, and can I limit it?

In US practice it commonly runs 30 to 60 days, sometimes longer. Sellers can ask for the shortest realistic period with no automatic extension, a fall-away if the buyer lowers the price or changes terms, and milestones such as evidence of financing and a first draft of the purchase agreement. The terms that decide the real price are best agreed before signing.

Is it safe to share information with a competitor who wants to buy us?

Only with care. The Federal Trade Commission has warned that sharing competitively sensitive information before closing, such as current and future prices, strategic plans and costs, can violate antitrust law, and recommends clean teams and third-party consultants for such data. Antitrust counsel should set the rules before the data room opens.

Should I talk to other buyers after an unsolicited offer?

Often it is worth knowing whether the first offer is the market. That does not require a public auction: a quiet approach to a few logical buyers before you sign exclusivity can be enough. If you hire an adviser, agree in the engagement letter how the buyer already at the table, the tail period and any minimum fee are treated.

Written by
Yevhen Borovoi
FounderYevhen Borovoi

Founder of PERETZ, DeZZign, The Structure and NEX, partner at SCHOEFFEL. An engineer by training who reads a business as one system: strategy, product, technology, processes and economics.

Next step

Preparing a sale or looking at a target?

We reply within one business day. NDA before any documents change hands.